Sunday, August 19, 2012

Graded rate of interest


At the initial stages of the project the Small & Medium scale entrepreneurs are enthusiastic, particularly in coordinating the funds for the project.  By and large they run around with the loan proposal for getting “Best Rate of Interest”, meaning Lowest Rate of Interest and also for lowest Processing Costs.  Their  Financial and non financial consultants also push them for such bargain. These probable entrepreneurs have tendency to approach more than one bank for such bargains. Entire focus is on keeping the cost of borrowings at the minimum level.  However, the rate of interest at the time of sanction is subject to change in future and it is possible to get the Rate of Interest reduced in subsequent years after the commercial production starts. 

Similar is the case with the existing units in SME Segment.  Many of the entrepreneurs are ignore about the process of what is known as “Risk Assessment “at branch level and therefore do not pay attention to the process of getting interest rates reduced during the Risk Appraisal by the bank at regular interval, generally a year or at the time of “renewal of the existing Cash Credit Limits” and thereby reduce the cost of borrowings instead of  bargaining or “Shopping” for it in the initial stages. I am discussing this subject from the Borrower’s perspective in the following paragraphs

Lending money involves risk for banks.  Therefore RBI has also issued various circulars for risk management by banks.  Risk management exercise is also vital function for the bank to estimate and monitor its Loan Assets.

Every individual Loan Account is a unique asset carrying specific degree of risk.  Therefore banks try to assess the risk involved in each account in a systematic method by giving least scope for subjectivity.  Accounts showing higher risk factor are closely monitored, or higher interest rates are applied to risky accounts as compared to the accounts carrying lower risk or higher comfort level.  Therefore it is possible to get the originally sanctioned interest rate reduced in subsequent “risk review” by the branches.



The Risk Assessment
Process involves answering a structured questionnaire.  Various questions are generated under each category of risk with Multiple Options for answers.  Predefined marks are given to the answers of each option. Therefore the officers assessing the risk do not have any Discretion or Discriminating Power. For example, following options and respective mark structure can be designed for Stock statements:
All statements are regular  in a year  12 Marks
Upto 2 defaults  in a year                   9 Marks
Upto 4 defaults  in a year                   8 Marks
More than 4 defaults in a year            6 Marks
In this case, the Risk Assessing Officer can not give 10 or 7 marks to any borrower even if he chooses to do so.
Various types of Risk areas attached to a Loan accounts can be classified as under
1.     Financial Risks
2.     Performance and Profitability
3.     Security Risks
4.     Management Risks
5.     Technology Risks
6.     Regulatory risks
7.     Industry Specific Risks
Financial Risks
While assessing the degree of Financial Risk in relation to any Loan account, the bank relies on the various financial ratios.  Important of them are TOL/TNW,  Retained Earnings (%), DSCR, DE Ratio for Term Loans and Current Ratio, Age of Debtors, Age of Creditors,  Working Capital Turnover Ratio etc are considered for assessing the risk of Working Capital Facilities.  Needless to say lesser is the risk if the ratios are favourable.



Security Risks
Bank reviews the value of security to ensure that market value of the Securities offered is adequate to cover the Loan outstanding through out the tenure of loan.  Situations like downward trend in the market value, Non Payment of installments, litigations if any after the disbursement, inadequate Insurance Cover etc may increase the risk of the bank.  Some times there can be a possibility of erosion of the Margin also and in that case risk is the maximum.  In respect of Stocks and Debtors, factors like realizable value of stocks, Shelf life of the stock, slow movement of finished goods, slower recovery of debtors, bad debts etc are important parameters to assess the risk relating to Securities.
           
Performance Risk
Bank also considers the performance of the borrower unit.  This is done by comparing the ratios of two consecutive periods.  Ratios and information like Change in Sales, Changes in GP and NP Ratio, Achievement of Sales and Net Profit vis-à-vis Projected Figures are considered first.  In the cases of units who achieve more than 80 % of the projections, comfort level is rated high. Similarly in the cases of borrowers showing improvement in ratios like TOL/TNW, NP Ratio, PAT/Sales (%) are considered less risky.   
Instances like timely regularization of temporary enhancements, Income generation from the account in the form of Commission, frequency of cheque-returns, timely retiring of L/c documents etc are also considered at the time of risk appraisal.  Punctuality in repaying all the installments during the year is another important factor deciding the degree of risk in the account.  Deposit patronage of the account is also an important parameter in assessing the Performance Risk

Management Risk
Factors such as background of the promoters, their experience in the field of business of the unit, this is very important aspect when the group of promoters have diverse business activities.  
Capability of raising additional finance, Succession Plan, Constitution of the borrower unit, Degree of professional approach, Organization chart and delegation of powers within the organization etc throw light on the degree of risk associated with the loan account.  Here more the professional approach of the management, safe succession plan, core competence of the management in the same line of business etc give higher comfort level to the bank.  Therefore such units are less risky.

Technology Risks
Up-gradation of technology is a continuous process, therefore, while assessing the degree of risk relating to technology of the borrower unit bank considers other sophisticated technology available, possibility of the existing machinery getting obsolete or useless.  Bank can also consider the plans of the borrower unit to upgrade its technology.   Technology used by the other competitors of the borrower unit will also influence the assessment of the bank.  Possibility of unit running successfully with the existing technology through out the tenure of loan is very important.   

Industry specific Risks
Each type of industry is exposed to specific risks attached to it.  Degree of consistency in the market to ensure profitability, liquidity, stability etc defers from industry to industry.  Some industries are more vulnerable to global changes;  in some cases industries are also complementary to each other and therefore sensitive to the developments in other dependant industries for example, upward trend in auto industry will boost many small contractors, ancillary or allied industry in Engineering, Petroleum Paint industry etc.,.  Therefore banks consider industry specific risks also. 

Regulatory Risks
Risks are also attributable to the changes in government policies and decisions.  For example, changes in Export-import policy, changes in customs duty, other indirect tax structure etc also play important role in the business of the borrower unit.  Risks associated with these are too considered in overall risk appraisal.


How gradation of a borrower account is made?
After allotting marks to the questions in the Risk appraisal questionnaire, grades are fixed on the basis of percentage of the marks obtained by that account  Borrower accounts scoring more than 90% marks are generally classified as Safe, degree of risk increases with decrease in the Marks. Accordingly, lesser the percentage of marks, bank manager classifies that account as risky or more risky.  This classification is nothing to do whether the account is  regular in payment or is classified as NPA for the purpose of finalization of the balance sheet of the bank.   Needless to say, all NPA Accounts are risky, but many of the Performing accounts can be classified as risky.

Here comes the challenge to the borrower.  During the year, he has to continuously monitor his account on the above lines.  The promoter must have regular watch on the operations of the account.  He must be vigilant about the audit objections raised by the bank auditors and rectify the errors found by him.  Promoter may not be able to show good performance every time developments in the economy and the market can be  beyond his control  but, he can score good marks by operating the account with strict discipline as regards
a.     regularization of temporary advances, if possible avoiding favours like withdrawals against clearing etc
b.    Not giving unrealistic projections
c.      retiring L/c documents in time
d.    Timely compliance of Renewal, Stock statement submission, renewing Insurance policies
e.     Timely submission of Balance sheet and Income Tax papers to the bank even if his CC Renewal is not due.
f.     Complying terms of sanction
g.    Rectifying the lapses  in the account which are pointed out by the Bank Auditors immediately preferably before the audit of the bank is completed.
h.     Keeping account within the drawing powers
i.      Maintaining good track records of installments of term loans

While finalizing the Balance Sheet, many of the promoters concentrate only on the Income Tax aspect.  But decisions to  maintain minimum Income tax liability  many times lead to adverse financial ratios.  Therefore he should consider various financial ratios also.  Some factors like maintaining profitability, maintaining good Current Ratio etc (1.33:1 is expected by the bank) may not be under control due to market pressures, but he should be alert in avoiding deteriorations in those ratios so that  he does not lose marks on it.

When you are successful in getting upward credit grades, banks do come forward and lower the rate of interest on the loans.  Safer the assessment of the account, more comfortable is the branch manager.

Incidentally many a times it is experienced that Credit appraisal work is pending with the branch manager for a long time.  Borrower should in his own interest get his Risk appraisal done periodically.

Internet services provided by IT Department


Income Tax Department is very rapidly providing internet based services to the tax payers. Barely three years back, it announced that the tax payers are not required to attach any documents along with his IT return. At that time nobody showed enough confidence on that announcement. Even there were few incidences where the department staff itself was insisting for the documents supporting Pre-paid taxes; and the department had to issue a press note stating that there is no such need.


The things have taken shape very rapidly. Today we are experiencing the efficiency of Income Tax Department & NSDL. A tax payer receives the data of his “TAX CREDIT” within 30 or 60 days from filing his return by E-mail from NSDL. This system is very much useful for reconciliation of claims of tax paid by the tax payer with the amount actually credited to his tax account. However, take the other side of this system; both the tax payer & tax deductor must work very accurately throughout the year.     


System of Reconciliation works as under:                                                  

While making payment in the bank, deductor gives only his TAN and the bank uploads only the details in the challan, which are as follows:
1.                     NAME
2.                     NATURE OF PAYMENT
3.                     CHALLAN NO.,BSR CODE

Before the Tax payer files the return, the deductee files for TDS return. Following information is submitted:

Challan Sr. No.

i.e. (TAN)
     (NAME)
     (AMOUNT)
     (NATURE    OF PAYMENT)
Name of the deductee, i.e. Tax payer
Then PAN, rate of deduction, date, amount received by him, amount of tax 












Suppose in Challan no. 1, the deductor has paid the tax of 15 different contractor the total amount of tax of all the 15 contractors must match the total amount of challan. Thus, the total of arithmetical accuracy is ensured in the beginning itself. 

The data regarding the income of the Tax payer as well as his Tax Credit is updated at IT Department before the due date for filing income tax Return.


The current income tax return includes a schedule for TDS 1 & TDS 2. The details given formulated by the tax payer in his ITR are cross verified with the data submitted by the tax payer. In case of mismatched challan, the tax credit is not given to the tax payer.
Therefore, the highest responsibility talls on the shoulders of the deductor of tax to furnish accurate information to NSDL TIN while uploading his quarterly TDS Return.

FINANCE BILL, 2012


Pronabda... when you started the budget speech on negative note, we, Chartered Accountants, got it that there are not going to be major tax reforms in this budget also (Refer in your speech:” For the Indian economy, this was a year of recovery interrupted. When one year ago, I rose to present the Budget, the challenges were many, but there was a sense that the world economy was on the mend. The Budget was presented in the first glimmer of hope. But reality turned out to be different.”). & so, we were eager to hear from you how do you manage to show that you have made enough efforts to bring in changes in the Indian taxation.
Now let us take a closer look at what you have proposed in the finance bill regarding Direct and Indirect Taxes. Before that, I would like to bring it to your notice that you had promised us in the last budget that “The introduction of the Direct Taxes Code (DTC) and the proposed Goods and Services Tax (GST) will mark a watershed. These reforms will result in moderation of rates, simplification of laws and better compliance”, which, has not yet happened and what you are doing is “we received the Report of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on March 9, 2012. We will examine the report expeditiously and take steps for the enactment of DTC at the earliest” and as far as GST is concerned, you had said in the last budget that “, decisions on the GST have to be taken in concert with the States with whom our dialogue has made considerable progress in the last four years” and now you said “we received the Report of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on March 9, 2012. We will examine the report expeditiously and take steps for the enactment of DTC at the earliest”. Well, you are doing everything at the earliest.
Now getting back to my favourite part of decoding the Bill. Let’s have a look what you have got for the common man this year!

Income Tax

Changes in the Rates of Income Tax slabs
Pronabda... how merciful of you to increase the Income Tax slabs quoting these sentences: “Last year I provided relief to individual taxpayers by enhancing the exemption limit as a move towards DTC rates.  Although DTC will not be effective from this year, I propose to introduce the DTC rates for personal income tax” and you did this:

Personal Income Tax Slabs:
Income                         Tax rates
Upto Rs. 2,00,000          Nil
2,00,000 – 5,00,000       10%
5,00,000 – 10,00,000      20%
Above 10,00,000            30%
I was surprised to see that slab for Woman Assessee is also the same & was wondering whether you are, thereby trying to achieve the equality. However, I was mainly impressed by the increase in second slab. That was indeed a good move and a step towards much awaited DTC.
  1. You proposed to give a deduction (amendment to Section 80D) of Rs 5000 for expenses incurred on preventive health check-up. Now we can get a tax benefit if we visit a neighbourhood hospital for a health check-up. And hope for it that the complete health check up will get over in Rs.5,000.
  2. Then you have proposed to give exemption vide newly inserted Section 80TTA for amount up to Rs.10,000 in saving account.
  3. & then there is good news for senior citizens who do not have income from business. You have exempted them from payment of advance tax.
  4. You have proposed to introduce Rajiv Gandhi Equity Savings Scheme. So, now we need to invest Rs.50,000 directly into Equity shares to get the exemption. But you have again played the favourite trick by saying further that this amount shall have the lock in period of three years. That means, even if we see the profit in those stocks, we will have to keep mum.
  5. I also find Section 54GB which you have introduced, very interesting. This is to encourage the SME industries. So now if any individual or HUF transfer the long term residential house property and the proceedings are invested in purchase of plant and machinery for the Manufacturing SME in which he/it owns more than fifty one percent stake, then capital gains arising from such transfer will be exempted. But I doubt how many will do this because while defining the Eligible Company you have mentioned that such company should be incorporated in the same previous year in which the capital gain has arisen. That means such individual or HUF needs to do pre-planned work and then sell the residential house property and buy the plant and machinery to avail the benefit!
  6. Again for SME sector, you have raised the limit of Tax Audit to Rs. 1 crore for manufacturing industry and Rs. 25 Lakhs for the service sector. Though  I personally felt this need 3 years ago, to raise these limits to these extents because seeing at the scenario that the turnover of Rs.1 cr is a very ordinary thing for manufacturing industry, so is Rs25 lakhs for service professionals. Anyway, better late than never.
  7. As far as Business and Corporate assessee goes, you have introduced some additional benefits but it is again for very limited sectors.
  8. Investment linked deduction of capital expenditure (Section 35AD) is proposed to be raised to 150% from current 100%. Moreover, you have added three more businesses in this category viz. Bee keeping and production of honey and beeswax,  container freight station and container depot & warehouse for storage of sugar.
9.  You have proposed to extend the weighted deduction of 200% on R & D expenditure for the period of 5 more years and have added agri-extension services in this category with a proposed weighted deduction of 150% on such expenditure.
10.  And for power sector, the sunset clause is again extended to one more year.
11.  And in order to recover the revenue lost from the “increase” in personal income tax slabs, you have spread the scope of Minimum Alternate tax (MAT) to non corporate business assesses as well, though keeping the rate of MAT unchanged.
12.  For Capital market investors there is a bit relief by way of reduction in Securities Transaction Tax to 0.1% on cash delivery transactions.
13.  And to discourage the generation and use of unaccounted money, you have proposed several measure which are as follows:
  • Introduction of compulsory reporting of assets held abroad – I wonder how the department is gonna keep tab on these people and ensure 100% compliance of your measure
  • Allowing the reopening of assessment upto 16 years in relation to assets held abroad
  • Tax collection at source on purchase of jewellery or bullion in cash in excess of Rs.2 lakhs – again, how are they going to trace these transactions? Even jewellers are happy to take the cash and skip the VAT tax to keep customer happy. And Pronabda, you are expecting them to collect tax at source.
  • TDS on transfer of immovable property (other than agricultural land) above a specified threshold.
  • TCS on trading in coal, lignite and iron ore.
  • Increase the burden of proof on closely held companies for funds received from shareholders as well as taxing share premium in excess of fair market value.
  • And the unexplained money, credits etc are proposed to be charged at the highest rate of tax i.e. 30%
14.  You then opened another surprise box for common man. Now if we want to buy a residential flat, we will have to deduct tax at source @ 1% and deposit it with the government. That means, those who are purchasing a house, should get ready to be registered with TDS circle and should file TDS return just for one lifetime transaction. Superb!!!

Service Tax & Excise
  1. You have tried to recover the revenue loss estimated from the changes in direct tax rates and other provisions by increasing the Service Tax rate to 12% and bringing in all the services under the service tax net
  2. You have still left a few services untouched like Entertainment industry; so that we can still watch movie at the same tickets rates & also go to Amusement parks at the same rates.  Also it was good to see that you have left out education industry and public transport services from the Service tax net.
  3. To encourage banks and financial services enterprises to provide services in rural areas, you have exempted the services of business facilitators and correspondents to banks and insurance companies.
  4. & then there is a good news for CA, ICWA and Law students. The Negative list stuff will result in reducing nearly 290 definitions and descriptions in the Act to 54, and the exemptions from the existing 88 to 10, of course merging some of the existing exemptions into a revised notification. In terms of number of pages, the law will be shorter by nearly 40 per cent.
  5. Coming to excise, you continued playing ladders and snakes just like your precedents. 14% to 8%, then 8% to 10% and now you proposed to raise it to 12% once again.
  6. What is wrong with you and cars, Sir? So many increases in various ways! Ad valorem rate of 27%, increase of ad valorem duty on SUVs/ large cars from 60% to 75%... that is going to discourage the buyers and the automobile index will be again affected.
  7. However, we can see that you have given quite a relief to agriculture sector by reducing basic customs duty and extending concessional import duty
  8. You have also proposed to exempt LCD, LED TV panel and Mobile Phone memory card parts which will eventually reduce the price of the said articles but at the same time due to increase in Service tax rate the mobile bill is going to surge; so your favourite game of “Iss Hath de, uss Hath le” continues successfully.
  9. In a country like India where gold is not only a metal but also deals with sentiments of people and when the prices of the gold are already high, you have proposed to increase the duty on the same to twice of what it was earlier. Also, you have brought unbranded jewellery except for silver ornament under ambit of excise duty of 1%.
10.  Smokers, it’s your turn now. Though any kind of price hike does not affect smokers, you have again proposed to increase the rate of duty by 10%.
11.  Crude Oil is also going to be more expensive on account of hike in rate of cess to Rs.4500 per MT.
As I rightly said earlier in this article, you have obviously recovered from Indirect Taxes what you lost in Direct taxes. Your estimates say that though you lose Rs.4,500 cr from direct taxes, you gain revenue of Rs.45,940 Cr and ultimately, a net gain of Rs.41,440Cr.
So Pronabda, your budget was more of fiscal deficite for “AAM AADMI” and not for Govt. As you said, for Indian economy, it was a challenging year. And post budget, it is going to be another challenging year for common man’s pocket economy.

Section 44AD of the Income Tax Act, 1961


The amended section 44AD of the Income Tax Act, 1961 is a worth study. Earlier, S.44AD was applicable only to the business of civil construction. However, Finance (No. 2) Act, 2009 has amended the said section w.e.f. 01/04/2011.

Apparently the section 44AD is very straightforward, but has lots of implications on the taxpayers.

44AD (1)
Section 44AD begins with the wordings “Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in sections 28 to 43C”. This means that if there is anything which is contradicting the provisions of Section 44AD, then the provisions mentioned in the section 44AD will override those provisions and such provisions will not be applicable. In short, provisions of section 44AD have overriding effect over sections 28 to 43C unless and until mentioned otherwise.

Thus, any specific disallowance like that of specified under section 40(a)(ia) – TDS compliances, 40A(3) – Cash payment above Rs. 20,000/- will not be applicable in case of eligible assessee carrying on eligible business.
Similarly, any specific expenditure will not be separately allowed unless and until specified otherwise, e.g. contribution to National Laboratory will not qualify for deduction u/S.35 (2AA) and so on.

Now let us understand who is an eligible assessee and which business is eligible for S.44AD.

Eligible assessee means,—
(i) an individual, Hindu undivided family or a partnership firm, who
is a resident, but not a limited liability partnership firm as defined
under clause (n) of sub-section (1) of section 2 of the Limited
Liability Partnership Act, 2008 (6 of 2009);

and

(ii) who has not claimed deduction under any of the sections 10A,
10AA, 10B, 10BA or deduction under any provisions of Chapter
VIA under the heading “C. - Deductions in respect of certain
incomes” in the relevant assessment year

Thus, Limited liability partnerships, Company, AOP, BOI, AJP and a non resident firm does not qualify as eligible assessee for the purpose of S. 44AD.

Also, if we see, the assessee to be eligible for the purpose of S. 44AD, must not claim any exemption or deduction u/S 10A, 10AA, 10B, 10BA or under chapter VI-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, as specified.

Eligible business means,—
(i) any business except the business of plying, hiring or leasing goods
carriages referred to in section 44AE;

and

 (ii) whose total turnover or gross receipts in the previous year does not
exceed an amount of One Crore rupees.

Thus, any business, except for the business of transporatation, whose turnover/ gross receipts are 100 lakhs or below, is an eligible business for the section 44AD.

The business of transportation is specifically covered by the provisions of S. 44AE, thus it is excluded.
Also, if we read it carefully, we can conclude that “the profession” is also excluded from the definition of eligible business for the purpose of S. 44AD. This is because, turnover limit for the purpose of tax audit of a profession is specified already as Rs.25 lakhs for AY 2014-15. Thus, the profession is out of the scope of S.44AD.

All rest of the businesses fall under the purview of Eligible business criteria of S. 44AD.

How to calculate total turnover/ gross receipts of the eligible business

The wording of subsec. (1) of S. 44AD is “the total turnover or gross receipts of the assessee
in the previous year on account of such business”. It uses the word “SUCH Business”. This means, total turnover of all the eligible businesses taken together.

E.g. if an assessee is carrying on 3 businesses. Their respective turnovers are as below

Business 1                                Rs. 60,00,000/-
Business 2                                Rs. 35,00,000/-
Business 3                                Rs. 20,00,000/-

Total turnover is Rs. 1,15,00,000/-. Thus, S. 44AD will not be applicable to this assessee.

Now if the assessee is carrying on two businesses as follows

Business 1                               Rs. 45,00,000/-
Profession 1                             Rs. 25,00,000/-

Though the total is Rs. 70, 00,000/-, since the business has got the turnover of Rs. 45 lakhs only, he is an eligible assessee and the business is also eligible for the purpose of S. 44AD.


What is meant by Income claimed to have been earned?

The wording used suggests that the assessee is not compelled to declare his actual profit/ gain from the eligible business if it is more than 8% of the turnover. The word “claimed” indicates that it is a right and not the obligation of the assessee to show more profit than 8% as specified. He may or may not exercise his right.

Case laws supporting this view:

            - Samta construction Co  V. Pawan Kumar sharma(2000) 244 ITR 845 (MP)

            - CIT V. ARVIND MIILS LTD(1992) 193 ITR 255(SC)

      - AC,BANGLORE VELLIAPA TEXTILES LIMITED AND ANOTHER (2003) ITR 560(SC)

44AD (2)
First part of the subsection 2 of section 44AD is quite easy enough to understand. Since the profit percentage is already determined by the subsection 1, no further deduction under sections 30 to 38 will be allowed to the assessee.

However, there is a proviso stating that in case of partnership firm, the remuneration or salary and interest paid to the partners shall be allowed separately subject to provisions of S. 40(b).

Now here is a trap! The remuneration and interest to partners are allowed, but subject to provisions of section 40(b). Section 40(b) is a disallowing section. It requires that in order to be an eligible deduction, remuneration and interest must be permitted by the deed of partnership. It also gives the upper limit/ ceiling for the remuneration to the partners and interest paid to the partners. Interest paid to partners is restricted to 12% whereas remuneration is restricted as follows:

In case of loss or upto first 3 lakhs of profit                      Rs.1,50,000 or 90% of the profit whichever is higher

On the balance amount, if any                                        60% of the profit

The “profit” is defined in explanation 3 to the section 40(b) as book profit as shown in the profit and loss account, computed as per the manner laid down in chapter IV-D of the Income Tax Act. Chapter IV-D means the Profit & Loss from business & profession. In that, Section 29 states how to compute profit from business/ profession. And it states that income from business/ profession shall be computed in accordance with the provisions contained in sections 30 to 43D.

Now, to calculate the limit/ restriction on remuneration u/S 40(b), for the purpose of section 44AD, which profit shall be considered, actual book profit or profit calculated on presumptive basis?

If we say actual profit, where are the books of accounts? Are they maintained? Does that mean, even if we are calculating income on presumptive basis, do we have to maintain books of accounts for the purpose of calculating remuneration to the partner?

Recall what we have discussed in earlier paragraphs. Section 44AD (1) starts with wordings “Notwithstanding anything contrary contained in S. 28 to 43C”. Clearly, Section 44AD will override the said sections and thus the profit to be taken for computation of limits of remuneration is the presumptive profit as computed under subsection (1) of section 44AD.

So, for example, turnover of the business is Rs.50,00,000/-
Profit @ 8% shall be Rs. 4,00,000/-
Remuneration as per deed is Rs.1,50,000/-
Interest is Rs. 1,00,000/-

The restriction will be cross checked taking Rs. 4,00,000/- as the base
So, on first Rs.3,00,000/-, 90% i.e. Rs. 2,70,000/-
On balance Rs. 1,00,000/-, 60% i.e. Rs. 60,000/-

Total limit is Rs. 3,30,000/-

Actual remuneration paid is Rs. 1,50,000/- which is well within the limit, thus allowed.

The computation will be

Profit As Per S. 44AD                                                               Rs. 4,00,000
Less: Remuneration                                                                  Rs. 1,50,000
Less: Interest                                                                            Rs. 1,00,000

Net Profit (taxable)                                                                    Rs. 1,50,000


44AD (3)
Subsection (3) of S. 44AD states that written down value of an asset, for the purpose of an eligible business, shall be deemed to be calculated. Thus, at the time of disposal or sale of the asset, such written down value shall be considered. Let’s take an example.

Mr. X has a machinery having WDV Rs.1,00,000/- on 31-03-2011. For the AY 2011-2012 he opts for 44AD and declares profit @ 8% of his turnover. For the next 2 years, he continues with this practice and in the third year he sells of the said machinery. So, calculation of STCG will be as follows.

WDV on 31.03.2011                                                       100000
(-) Depreciation @ 15%                                                    15000
WDV on 31.03.2012                                                         85000
(-) Depreciation @ 15%                                                    12750
WDV on 31.03.2013                                                         72250
(-) Sold during the year                                                    75000

Computation of Short Term Capital Gain

Sale Consideration                                                        75000
(-) WDV as on 31.03.2013                                            72250

STCG                                                                             2750

44AD (4)
This subsection says that the eligible assessee is not required to pay advance tax. However, second part of the provision is little tricky. The wording is “So far as it relates to eligible business”.

This means that if there is any other source of income than the eligible business, then the provisions of chapter XVII-C shall be applicable to that particular income.

From practical point of view, this is going to be a very complicated situation. Excluding a particular income and estimating the remaining income for the purpose of advance tax computation is really a complicated calculation. But that is how the Indian Law is!!!

44AD (5)
Subsection (5) contains the most interesting provision in this whole section 44AD. It says that the eligible assessee can claim lower income than what is prescribed u/s 44AD (1). However, the assessee will have to maintain books of accounts as mentioned u/s 44AA and shall have to get those books audited u/s 44AB.
In case of loss, also, the assessee needs to get its accounts audited and get the tax audit done. Because, loss, though negative profit, is chargeable to tax and that is why we carry it forward and take the benefit of it.
However, there is a twist in the provision. The provision says “and whose total income exceeds the maximum amount which is not chargeable to income-tax”. This means that if the TOTAL INCOME of the eligible assessee is less than the exemption limit i.e. Rs.200000/- for AY 2014-15, then even if he is showing lower profit than profit as per S. 44AD (1), he need not maintain the books or get the accounts audited. But the important thing to be kept in mind is “TOTAL Income” must not exceed the exemption limit. So, we have to consider all the sources of income to arrive at Total Income.

This provision, from revenue point of view, is actually not favoring them. This may give the scope to conceal the income to any dishonest person. But this is the way Indian Income Tax Act is!!!

Carry forward & set off of losses from Eligible business
The loss from any eligible business can be set off against profit from another eligible business only. Also, if any loss is carried forward, then it shall be adjusted only against eligible business in the consequent year.
The possibility of loss in case of S. 44AD arises only in case of partnership firm as two separate deductions are allowed to be adjusted against the presumptive income.

By introducing this section 44AD, the Income Tax Act has widened its net for all the businesses. The assesses who are showing their income below the specified percentage of 8%, are brought under the scope of Tax Audit.
Thus, is this provision beneficial to the assessee or not, is totally subjective i.e. differs from assessee to assessee and their businesses.

Contact me at +91-9920 20 2625 or mail your query at mandarjoshiandco@gmail.com