At
the initial stages of the project the Small & Medium scale entrepreneurs
are enthusiastic, particularly in coordinating the funds for the project. By and large they run around with the loan
proposal for getting “Best Rate of Interest”, meaning Lowest Rate of Interest
and also for lowest Processing Costs.
Their Financial and non financial
consultants also push them for such bargain. These probable entrepreneurs have
tendency to approach more than one bank for such bargains. Entire focus is on
keeping the cost of borrowings at the minimum level. However, the rate of interest at the time of
sanction is subject to change in future and it is possible to get the Rate of
Interest reduced in subsequent years after the commercial production
starts.
Similar
is the case with the existing units in SME Segment. Many of the entrepreneurs are ignore about
the process of what is known as “Risk Assessment “at branch level and therefore
do not pay attention to the process of getting interest rates reduced during
the Risk Appraisal by the bank at regular interval, generally a year or at the
time of “renewal of the existing Cash Credit Limits” and thereby reduce the
cost of borrowings instead of bargaining
or “Shopping” for it in the initial stages. I am discussing this subject from
the Borrower’s perspective in the following paragraphs
Lending
money involves risk for banks. Therefore
RBI has also issued various circulars for risk management by banks. Risk management exercise is also vital
function for the bank to estimate and monitor its Loan Assets.
Every
individual Loan Account is a unique asset carrying specific degree of risk. Therefore banks try to assess the risk
involved in each account in a systematic method by giving least scope for
subjectivity. Accounts showing higher
risk factor are closely monitored, or higher interest rates are applied to risky
accounts as compared to the accounts carrying lower risk or higher comfort
level. Therefore it is possible to get
the originally sanctioned interest rate reduced in subsequent “risk review” by
the branches.
The Risk Assessment
Process
involves answering a structured questionnaire.
Various questions are generated under each category of risk with
Multiple Options for answers. Predefined
marks are given to the answers of each option. Therefore the officers assessing
the risk do not have any Discretion or Discriminating Power. For example, following
options and respective mark structure can be designed for Stock statements:
All statements are regular in a year
12 Marks
Upto 2 defaults in
a year 9 Marks
Upto 4 defaults in
a year 8 Marks
More than 4 defaults in a year 6 Marks
In
this case, the Risk Assessing Officer can not give 10 or 7 marks to any
borrower even if he chooses to do so.
Various
types of Risk areas attached to a Loan accounts can be classified as under
1. Financial
Risks
2. Performance
and Profitability
3. Security
Risks
4. Management
Risks
5. Technology
Risks
6. Regulatory
risks
7. Industry
Specific Risks
Financial Risks
While
assessing the degree of Financial Risk in relation to any Loan account, the bank
relies on the various financial ratios.
Important of them are TOL/TNW,
Retained Earnings (%), DSCR, DE Ratio for Term Loans and Current Ratio,
Age of Debtors, Age of Creditors, Working
Capital Turnover Ratio etc are considered for assessing the risk of Working
Capital Facilities. Needless to say
lesser is the risk if the ratios are favourable.
Security Risks
Bank
reviews the value of security to ensure that market value of the Securities
offered is adequate to cover the Loan outstanding through out the tenure of
loan. Situations like downward trend in
the market value, Non Payment of installments, litigations if any after the disbursement,
inadequate Insurance Cover etc may increase the risk of the bank. Some times there can be a possibility of
erosion of the Margin also and in that case risk is the maximum. In respect of Stocks and Debtors, factors
like realizable value of stocks, Shelf life of the stock, slow movement of
finished goods, slower recovery of debtors, bad debts etc are important
parameters to assess the risk relating to Securities.
Performance Risk
Bank
also considers the performance of the borrower unit. This is done by comparing the ratios of two
consecutive periods. Ratios and
information like Change in Sales, Changes in GP and NP Ratio, Achievement of
Sales and Net Profit vis-à-vis Projected Figures are considered first. In the cases of units who achieve more than
80 % of the projections, comfort level is rated high. Similarly in the cases of
borrowers showing improvement in ratios like TOL/TNW, NP Ratio, PAT/Sales (%)
are considered less risky.
Instances
like timely regularization of temporary enhancements, Income generation from the
account in the form of Commission, frequency of cheque-returns, timely retiring
of L/c documents etc are also considered at the time of risk appraisal. Punctuality in repaying all the installments
during the year is another important factor deciding the degree of risk in the account.
Deposit patronage of the account is also
an important parameter in assessing the Performance Risk
Management Risk
Factors
such as background of the promoters, their experience in the field of business
of the unit, this is very important aspect when the group of promoters have
diverse business activities.
Capability of raising
additional finance, Succession Plan, Constitution of the borrower unit, Degree
of professional approach, Organization chart and delegation of powers within
the organization etc throw light on the degree of risk associated with the loan
account. Here more the professional
approach of the management, safe succession plan, core competence of the
management in the same line of business etc give higher comfort level to the
bank. Therefore such units are less
risky.
Technology Risks
Up-gradation
of technology is a continuous process, therefore, while assessing the degree of
risk relating to technology of the borrower unit bank considers other
sophisticated technology available, possibility of the existing machinery
getting obsolete or useless. Bank can
also consider the plans of the borrower unit to upgrade its technology. Technology used by the other competitors of
the borrower unit will also influence the assessment of the bank. Possibility of unit running successfully with
the existing technology through out the tenure of loan is very important.
Industry specific Risks
Each
type of industry is exposed to specific risks attached to it. Degree of consistency in the market to ensure
profitability, liquidity, stability etc defers from industry to industry. Some industries are more vulnerable to global
changes; in some cases industries are
also complementary to each other and therefore sensitive to the developments in
other dependant industries for example, upward trend in auto industry will
boost many small contractors, ancillary or allied industry in Engineering,
Petroleum Paint industry etc.,.
Therefore banks consider industry specific risks also.
Regulatory Risks
Risks
are also attributable to the changes in government policies and decisions. For example, changes in Export-import policy,
changes in customs duty, other indirect tax structure etc also play important
role in the business of the borrower unit.
Risks associated with these are too considered in overall risk
appraisal.
How gradation of a borrower
account is made?
After allotting marks to the
questions in the Risk appraisal questionnaire, grades are fixed on the basis of
percentage of the marks obtained by that account Borrower accounts scoring more than 90% marks
are generally classified as Safe, degree of risk increases with decrease in the
Marks. Accordingly, lesser the percentage of marks, bank manager classifies
that account as risky or more risky.
This classification is nothing to do whether the account is regular in payment or is classified as NPA
for the purpose of finalization of the balance sheet of the bank. Needless to say, all NPA Accounts are risky,
but many of the Performing accounts can be classified as risky.
Here
comes the challenge to the borrower. During the year, he has to continuously
monitor his account on the above lines.
The promoter must have regular watch on the operations of the
account. He must be vigilant about the
audit objections raised by the bank auditors and rectify the errors found by
him. Promoter may not be able to show
good performance every time developments in the economy and the market can
be beyond his control but, he can score good marks by operating the
account with strict discipline as regards
a. regularization
of temporary advances, if possible avoiding favours like withdrawals against
clearing etc
b. Not
giving unrealistic projections
c. retiring L/c documents in time
d. Timely
compliance of Renewal, Stock statement submission, renewing Insurance policies
e. Timely
submission of Balance sheet and Income Tax papers to the bank even if his CC
Renewal is not due.
f. Complying
terms of sanction
g. Rectifying
the lapses in the account which are
pointed out by the Bank Auditors immediately preferably before the audit of the
bank is completed.
h. Keeping
account within the drawing powers
i. Maintaining
good track records of installments of term loans
While
finalizing the Balance Sheet, many of the promoters concentrate only on the
Income Tax aspect. But decisions to maintain minimum Income tax liability many times lead to adverse financial ratios. Therefore he should consider various
financial ratios also. Some factors like
maintaining profitability, maintaining good Current Ratio etc (1.33:1 is
expected by the bank) may not be under control due to market pressures, but he
should be alert in avoiding deteriorations in those ratios so that he does not lose marks on it.
When
you are successful in getting upward credit grades, banks do come forward and
lower the rate of interest on the loans.
Safer the assessment of the account, more comfortable is the branch
manager.
Incidentally
many a times it is experienced that Credit appraisal work is pending with the
branch manager for a long time. Borrower
should in his own interest get his Risk appraisal done periodically.